Why regular exercise may impact men and women differently

Exercise is vital to a healthy lifestyle, offering numerous benefits such as improved heart health, elevated mood and better weight management. However, research increasingly suggests that exercise affects men and women differently.

Understanding these differences can help you tailor your workout plan to better meet your needs and goals.

While exercise affects men and women differently, the primary benefits remain the same.

Why exercise is crucial

Incorporating regular movement into your routine is one of the most powerful steps you can take for your overall health and well-being. Here’s why exercise is essential for both men and women…

• Keeps your heart strong: Regular exercise strengthens your cardiovascular system and enhances blood circulation, reducing the risk of heart disease.
• Boosts your mood and mind: Exercise triggers the release of feel-good endorphins, combating stress and anxiety.
• Fires up your metabolism: Staying active helps you burn calories, build muscle and maintain a healthy weight.
• Supports healthy veins: Physical activity strengthens your vein valves, improving blood flow and preventing issues like varicose veins.
• Builds stronger muscles and joints: Resistance exercises fortify your muscles and joints, keeping them strong and resilient against injury.

How does exercise affect men and women differently?

Men and women experience the benefits of exercise in unique ways, influenced by differences in hormones, metabolism, body composition and psychological factors. These factors shape how each gender responds to movement.

Here’s a look at why exercise might impact men and women differently and what that means for your fitness journey.

Hormonal differences

One of the primary reasons men and women may respond differently to exercise is hormonal. Men typically have higher testosterone levels – crucial for muscle growth and recovery. This means they often build muscle more quickly and efficiently than women when resistance training.

On the other hand, women have higher estrogen levels, which influences how their bodies store fat and use energy during exercise. Estrogen is associated with increased fat storage, particularly around the hips and thighs. This hormonal profile can make it more challenging for women to lose fat in these areas, even with regular exercise.

However, estrogen may promote better endurance, allowing women to perform better in activities that require sustained energy, such as long-distance running.

Metabolism and fat distribution

Men and women also have different metabolic rates and patterns of fat utilization during exercise. Men generally have a higher resting metabolic rate (RMR) due to their greater muscle mass, which burns more calories at rest. This means they may find it much easier to lose or maintain weight with regular exercise.

Women tend to be more efficient at using fat as a fuel source during exercise, particularly at moderate intensities. This difference in fat utilization is partly due to hormonal influences and can be advantageous for women in endurance sports, like swimming or running.

However, it may also mean they burn fewer carbohydrates during exercise, impacting their performance in high-intensity activities that rely heavily on glycogen stores.

Injury risk and recovery times

The risk of injury and recovery times can also differ between men and women. Women are generally more prone to certain types of injuries, such as anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tears, mainly due to differences in hip and pelvis mobility.

Bone destiny and muscle strength differences also pose greater injury risks. Additionally, women may take longer to recover from intense exercise, especially during certain phases of their menstrual cycle when estrogen and progesterone levels fluctuate.

Men, while generally less prone to injuries like ACL tears, may experience more strain on their cardiovascular system during high-intensity workouts. They tend to recover more quickly due to higher testosterone levels, which aids muscle repair and growth.

Psychological and behavioral responses

Men and women also differ in their psychological and behavioral responses to exercise. Research suggests men are more likely to engage in competitive and high-intensity workouts, often prioritizing muscle gain and performance enhancement. Women may focus on exercise for weight management or stress relief.

These differing motivations influence how men and women approach their fitness routines, with men potentially focusing more on strength training and women on activities like yoga, Pilates or cardio.

Additionally, societal pressures and body image concerns can play a role – particularly for women – who may feel more pressure to achieve a certain physique, influencing their exercise choices and behaviors.

How does this impact exercise programming?

It’s crucial to consider these differences when designing fitness programs to maximize effectiveness and reduce the risk of sprains and strains. For men, incorporating resistance training with progressive overload can lead to significant strength and muscle gains.

High-intensity interval training (HIIT) can also be particularly beneficial for men, capitalizing on their higher metabolic rates and capacity for speedy recovery. Programs challenging endurance and power simultaneously are well-suited to men’s physiological profiles.

For women, exercise programming might benefit from a more varied approach that balances strength training with endurance and flexibility exercise. Women typically have a higher proportion of type I muscle fibers, which are more resistant to fatigue and are better suited to sustained activities. As a result, endurance training and moderate-intensity movements can be particularly effective.

Additionally, since women are more prone to injuries, incorporating exercises that enhance joint stability and balance is crucial. Attention to recovery is critical, especially during menstrual cycle phases when injury risk is heightened.

Behavioral factors should also be considered. Women may respond more positively to group-based activities or programs emphasizing community and support, which boosts motivation and adherence. Men might thrive in environments that encourage competition and measurable progress.

Understanding these motivational differences can help create personalized programs that meet physical needs and align with psychological tendencies.

Play to your strengths

The key principles of exercise – consistency, progression and variety – apply to everyone. However, recognizing the physiological and psychological differences between men and women can enhance the effectiveness of any fitness program.

By tailoring exercise routines and playing to strengths, both men and women can optimize their health and performance, easily achieving their fitness goals.

I’d love it if you’d check-out more of my work. All you have to do is tap the links in my author box just below.

For Bill’s Chipur info and information articles, review all of the titles or by category – scroll down on mobile, right sidebar on desktop.

Beth is the mental health editor at Body+Mind. She has five-plus years of experience writing about behavioral health, specifically mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. Beth also writes about the power of human design to reveal our full potential and purpose. You can find her on X @bodymindmag.